What a week in the market. I have all but given up on predicting direction. I remain short, but it really hurt me this past week. Still, I think this is a bear market rally & the S&P will break through its lows by the end of March.
Why? Because the primary driver of GDP growth over the last 15 years or so has been consumption. Conspicuous consumption is dead. (for now) See GDP (otherwise known as Gross Domestic Product) = C + G + I, where C =consumption G=government spending and I= investment. This is a very basic explanation. If you want more detail read:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_domestic_product
When an economy is growing, GDP is increasing. When an economy is contracting, it is decreasing. "Keynesian" economics is a school of economic thought says that the government can and should intervene in economies to "smooth" the business cycle. This can be temporarily effective. It can slow economies when they grow too quickly. It can "stimulate" economies when they are contracting.
GDP is contracting right now, and has been since December 2007 because consumers are dramatically reducing their spending. Keynesian policies that have worked to stimulate demand are not working anymore. In other words, the "C" in GDP is falling off a cliff... no matter what the Government does. In the Fortune Encyclopedia of Economics, 1993 edition, I found the following in the section on GDP:
"GDP measures production, not exchange. If economists, policymakers, and news commentators kept this simple truth in mind, much confusion over the interpretation of economic statistics might be avoided. Many proposals to cut taxes, for example, are aimed at 'stimulating consumer spending', which is expected to cause an increase in GDP. But consumer spending is a use of GDP, not production. A rise in consumer demand could simply crowd out investment, not raise GDP." The writing goes on to explain that in the short run, Keynesian emphasis on demand is, "relevant and alluring". But, government reliance in "demand management" can "distort market prices, generate major inefficiencies, and destroy production incentives." Sound familiar? Is it possible that we are currently experiencing the effects of years of government binging on Keynesian policies to artificially prop up demand (consumer spending)? I not only think it is possible, I think it is true.
Now that propping up consumption is no longer working, the government is going to drastically increase the "G" in the formula above. We already see this beginning with all the bailouts and no doubt we will see it in Obama's New, New Deal.
These policies will lead us into a socialist state. I am sad to say this is where we are headed. I can only hope there are enough people out there who will grasp what is happening and try to save our country.
Luckily, the market, like the"force" in Star Wars has a way of letting us know when things are out of whack. They are very out of whack right now. If we try to fight gravity by "propping up demand" we only continue dependence on the same policies that created this mess in the first place.
Check out how much America has been consuming:
http://people.hofstra.edu/geotrans/eng/ch5en/conc5en/leadingtraders.html
Look where government spending is headed:
http://www.gao.gov/cghome/hccrisis/img6.html
Try to get a good night's sleep, anyway.
Saturday, December 6, 2008
Guest Blogger
My beautiful daughter is my guest blogger tonight. I had to work late and she is still awake. So I asked her if she wanted to help with my blog. Here is what she has to say:
"I am proud of my mom for making her own blog site. I like that she came up with the title econ mom. My day was good. Today we rehearsed songs on the stages in the cafeteria. We sang "Happy Talk", "Under The Sea", and another song that I can't remember the name of. I cannot sleep because yesterday I went to sleep late and tonight I think I am going to fall asleep at the same time I did yesterday. I already read a book called "Fantastic Mr. Fox" by Roald Dahl. I think it is really cool. I understand I am talking about random topics, but I don't care.
WHAT IS THE PROBLEM WITH ADULTS?: They are old and grumpy. I know that I should listen to my parents or other adults but sometimes they get annoying. No offense.
MY BROTHER: He likes guns, swords, a game called Command & Conquer, & he likes to flick me. I do not like when he flicks me. I have to say that I am not always nice to my brother. I still love my brother even though sometimes he can be a pain in the neck.
SCHOOL: I think fourth grade is a little more challenging than third grade and under. But I am very glad that I have a boy teacher because he is very nice and I've always had girl teachers.
HOW TO ACHIEVE WORLD PEACE: People being nice. Recycling. And I don't know much more about that.
WHAT I LIKE: I only like to read good books. I like science. I like Webkinz. I like lemon tea.
WHAT I HATE: I hate it when my hair gets all full of static in winter. I also hate onions. I hate a boy in my class. I hate hate homework.
GROWN UPS SHOULD: Listen to kids more. Sometimes let their kids, if they have any, be wild. Let them stay up a little later on weekends, but, I have to say sorry to my mom because she is letting me stay up late right now That is all I have to say. Bye "
"I am proud of my mom for making her own blog site. I like that she came up with the title econ mom. My day was good. Today we rehearsed songs on the stages in the cafeteria. We sang "Happy Talk", "Under The Sea", and another song that I can't remember the name of. I cannot sleep because yesterday I went to sleep late and tonight I think I am going to fall asleep at the same time I did yesterday. I already read a book called "Fantastic Mr. Fox" by Roald Dahl. I think it is really cool. I understand I am talking about random topics, but I don't care.
WHAT IS THE PROBLEM WITH ADULTS?: They are old and grumpy. I know that I should listen to my parents or other adults but sometimes they get annoying. No offense.
MY BROTHER: He likes guns, swords, a game called Command & Conquer, & he likes to flick me. I do not like when he flicks me. I have to say that I am not always nice to my brother. I still love my brother even though sometimes he can be a pain in the neck.
SCHOOL: I think fourth grade is a little more challenging than third grade and under. But I am very glad that I have a boy teacher because he is very nice and I've always had girl teachers.
HOW TO ACHIEVE WORLD PEACE: People being nice. Recycling. And I don't know much more about that.
WHAT I LIKE: I only like to read good books. I like science. I like Webkinz. I like lemon tea.
WHAT I HATE: I hate it when my hair gets all full of static in winter. I also hate onions. I hate a boy in my class. I hate hate homework.
GROWN UPS SHOULD: Listen to kids more. Sometimes let their kids, if they have any, be wild. Let them stay up a little later on weekends, but, I have to say sorry to my mom because she is letting me stay up late right now That is all I have to say. Bye "
Wednesday, December 3, 2008
What Children Need
Children need time, attention (conscious attention), love, & food and water. Therefore, I will not be blogging tonight. My kids need me.
Have a good night!
Have a good night!
Monday, December 1, 2008
Bernanke Amazes Me
I was watching the "fally" fall apart today on CNBC. They panned to a speech Bernanke was giving at an economic conference. I tuned in just in time for the question and answer period. I could not believe my ears but I thought I heard Bernanke, a self-proclaimed "expert" on the Great Depression say that, "there is no comparison" between the situation we are now facing and the Great Depression he has so avidly studied. Now, I want to know, what exactly has he been studying? No, seriously, I am not being sarcastic. I know I am nowhere near as smart as Bernanke. But, I have been fascinated with the Great Depression for years, and I have read at least three academic books, two of them were very dry and technical, but full of good information nonetheless. The third, I am still reading. It is by far the best of the three. ('The Forgotten Man' by Amity Shlaes) I would recommend it for everyone.
Now, I know I am no Bernanke. I am, however, smart enough to realize that THIS PERIOD IS VERY SIMILAR TO THE GREAT DEPRESSION ERA in more ways than one. We are facing:
1) The unwinding of a very large asset bubble. (Housing was the trigger in this case.)
2) A period of steep deflation in the value of many hard assets.
3) A global recession.
4) A dramatic decline in stock prices.
(part of the asset deflation)
5) Government intervention on a massive scale. (New Deal type policies on the horizon)
6) Massive failures in the financial services sector. (Leman, AIG, Citi, Etc.)
So, what exactly does Bernanke mean when he says the era's are not comparable? I might just be cynical enough to think he is trying to prevent being replaced by OBAMA.
Bernanke says we will be better off this time because the FRB is going to hold interest rates very low and the government won't be protectionist. He also says the economy is so much bigger now that the consequences of a global slowdown won't be as severe as they were back then.
What am I missing here? Am I to read in to his comments that he intends to inflate the money supply to such a degree that a depression is impossible? Is he just so brilliant that he an his board of governors can stop a very large interconnected global economy from faltering? Can he single-handedly create a new asset bubble to replace the old one? Are federal reserve governors just inherently SMARTER now because of evolution than they were in the 1930's? Oh, that's probably true. What an arrogant.......OK, I'll stop now. I think you get the picture.
Needless to say I would love it if someone out there, economist or not, could give me some hard evidence as to why the downturn we are facing is different than the Great Depression. I mean it, I really want to be wrong on this one.
Please read:
http://www.forbes.com/afxnewslimited/feeds/afx/2008/10/15/afx5559042.html
and
http://www.forbes.com/reuters/feeds/reuters/2008/12/01/2008-12-01T194048Z_01_WBT010190_RTRIDST_0_USA-FED-BERNANKE-DEPRESSION-URGENT.html
Now, I know I am no Bernanke. I am, however, smart enough to realize that THIS PERIOD IS VERY SIMILAR TO THE GREAT DEPRESSION ERA in more ways than one. We are facing:
1) The unwinding of a very large asset bubble. (Housing was the trigger in this case.)
2) A period of steep deflation in the value of many hard assets.
3) A global recession.
4) A dramatic decline in stock prices.
(part of the asset deflation)
5) Government intervention on a massive scale. (New Deal type policies on the horizon)
6) Massive failures in the financial services sector. (Leman, AIG, Citi, Etc.)
So, what exactly does Bernanke mean when he says the era's are not comparable? I might just be cynical enough to think he is trying to prevent being replaced by OBAMA.
Bernanke says we will be better off this time because the FRB is going to hold interest rates very low and the government won't be protectionist. He also says the economy is so much bigger now that the consequences of a global slowdown won't be as severe as they were back then.
What am I missing here? Am I to read in to his comments that he intends to inflate the money supply to such a degree that a depression is impossible? Is he just so brilliant that he an his board of governors can stop a very large interconnected global economy from faltering? Can he single-handedly create a new asset bubble to replace the old one? Are federal reserve governors just inherently SMARTER now because of evolution than they were in the 1930's? Oh, that's probably true. What an arrogant.......OK, I'll stop now. I think you get the picture.
Needless to say I would love it if someone out there, economist or not, could give me some hard evidence as to why the downturn we are facing is different than the Great Depression. I mean it, I really want to be wrong on this one.
Please read:
http://www.forbes.com/afxnewslimited/feeds/afx/2008/10/15/afx5559042.html
and
http://www.forbes.com/reuters/feeds/reuters/2008/12/01/2008-12-01T194048Z_01_WBT010190_RTRIDST_0_USA-FED-BERNANKE-DEPRESSION-URGENT.html
Sunday, November 30, 2008
What Is Real Value?
A question has been floating around in my mind today. I was thinking about prices. I was having a discussion with my husband about what the price of something should be. His point was that everything has different value to different people.
True. I have friends that enjoy scrapbooking. I however, do not. These women seem to really enjoy their hobby. I have to admit, I wish I liked it. I somehow feel I am lacking in femininity because I can't stand to scrapbook. I like looking at the wonderful books these people put together. Perhaps my children will wish they had one someday. Alas, they will only have CD Rom's and boxes full of pictures of themselves. I guess I am OK with that. But the real point is this: to me, scrapbooking supplies have little or no value, therefore, I wouldn't spend much if anything on them. But to many women (let's face it, it is almost only women who do this activity), they are extremely valuable. They literally are willing to spend hundreds, if not thousands of dollars on pretty paper. The person who receives the higher utility from a certain product, is willing to pay more for it. Without this there would be no markets, no arbitrage, no speculation. This is all fine and good. But it ultimately means that value is subjective.
I am having trouble with this idea. I really want value to be objective. But it isn't. It just isn't. The marketplace is what it is; and isn't it cool? If value were objective, I couldn't make money trading stocks. If value were objective, everyone would be willing to pay the same amount for scrapbooking supplies. Pehaps the best markets can do is get the prices of goods as close to their true value as possible through trading.
My old economics professors would probably laugh at me, "DUH". But it still fascinates me.
If you can think of a good or a commodity that has objective value please comment & explain your thoughts. I would love to hear them.
True. I have friends that enjoy scrapbooking. I however, do not. These women seem to really enjoy their hobby. I have to admit, I wish I liked it. I somehow feel I am lacking in femininity because I can't stand to scrapbook. I like looking at the wonderful books these people put together. Perhaps my children will wish they had one someday. Alas, they will only have CD Rom's and boxes full of pictures of themselves. I guess I am OK with that. But the real point is this: to me, scrapbooking supplies have little or no value, therefore, I wouldn't spend much if anything on them. But to many women (let's face it, it is almost only women who do this activity), they are extremely valuable. They literally are willing to spend hundreds, if not thousands of dollars on pretty paper. The person who receives the higher utility from a certain product, is willing to pay more for it. Without this there would be no markets, no arbitrage, no speculation. This is all fine and good. But it ultimately means that value is subjective.
I am having trouble with this idea. I really want value to be objective. But it isn't. It just isn't. The marketplace is what it is; and isn't it cool? If value were objective, I couldn't make money trading stocks. If value were objective, everyone would be willing to pay the same amount for scrapbooking supplies. Pehaps the best markets can do is get the prices of goods as close to their true value as possible through trading.
My old economics professors would probably laugh at me, "DUH". But it still fascinates me.
If you can think of a good or a commodity that has objective value please comment & explain your thoughts. I would love to hear them.
Friday, November 28, 2008
Commercial Opportunity?
Just when I thought the world was starting to make some sense, I read this article:
http://www.cnbc.com/id/27930515
The link to the article above will tell you why there are some really good investments in commercial real estate bonds right now.
THIS IS MADNESS!!! Whatever you do, DO NOT go out and buy commercial real estate bonds. This article would have millions of people buying the garbage because the yield is high.
Remember that a bond is just a loan. A commercial real estate bond is just a loan from private investors to commercial real estate thieves. These things are junk. The reason they are paying such a high rate of return is because if you invest in them you WILL NEVER SEE YOUR PRINCIPAL again. Don't do it - high yields often mean high risk. Have you driven around town lately to see what is happening to commercial real estate?
These guys are so desperate for new "investors" (i. e. "suckers") they will do anything to get your hard earned cash. The banks have already realized they are crooks - don't become the lender of last resort.
Also, please do not rush into stocks because the headlines are saying we are in for the biggest bear market rally since 1933. Stop and think about that for a moment. 1933! Where exactly were we bouncing from back then?
Please pull out your historical charts.
http://stockcharts.com/charts/historical/djia1900.html
If you are a trader, or an investment advisor with years of experience, you may be able to play this rally. If you are not, please don't buy all the bull shit you hear. These people have a vested interest in selling stocks.
I remember my days as an intern at a certain "financial planning" company. I worked as an assistant to financial planners. I decided NOT to be a financial planner because of what was going on there. (Granted, there are some very good financial planners out there, but they are not the flashy kind of guys and gals that most people gravitate toward.)
I also remember my days as an Investment Sales Representative (and later Supervisor) at your local community bank. I remember the feeling I got when I would put people in the appropriate product for their risk tolerance & time horizon. I knew I had done the right thing for the customer, but I knew I would soon be called in to my manager's office, after selling a boring CD or Annuity to an 70 year old lady. It was approximately 1997.
"Why didn't you sell them on mutual funds? You know you get a higher commission?" To which I would answer, "It didn't seem appropriate, given her risk profile." The boss would then say, but didn't you show her the CHART?" The "CHART" was a graph showing the S&P 500 and it's gains since 1955 or so. I would counter that it wasn't an accurate chart to show, because it did not accurately portray the risk associated with stock investments. It excluded the time period from 1929 to 1954. This woman was retired. She needed her last $200,000 in the world to live off of. I wasn't being a good steward if I put her in risky assets. My boss would act very irritated and make suggestions under his breath that I would be better in operations. And so it was, eventually I moved into operations, which I loved. Sales was not for me.
Now, this is not to say that if this woman would have been 30, 40, or maybe even 50 with a lot of assets, that I wouldn't have recommended mutual funds as part of her portfolio. I would have; IF her risk tolerance and time horizon were appropriate. But, you see, this wasn't very good for sales. I was too smart for sales, or to honest. I would do much better in operations. And I did.
I am currently reading a book by Aaron Clarey called, "Behind The Housing Crash". It reminds me of what I was experiencing back in the day. He was going through a very similar thing as a credit analyst not long after I was listening to my bosses tell me why mutual funds would always go up over time. Buy his book - it is worth every penny. I laughed out loud in several parts, probably because I could relate, although in a different time and place. I was worried about the dot-com bubble at the time, and how it had inflated stocks. A little while later, he was worried about the housing bubble, and he was right to be worried. Anyway, it is a great read, especially if you want to understand the nature of the housing bubble.
OK - that was a tangent. Goodnight.
http://www.cnbc.com/id/27930515
The link to the article above will tell you why there are some really good investments in commercial real estate bonds right now.
THIS IS MADNESS!!! Whatever you do, DO NOT go out and buy commercial real estate bonds. This article would have millions of people buying the garbage because the yield is high.
Remember that a bond is just a loan. A commercial real estate bond is just a loan from private investors to commercial real estate thieves. These things are junk. The reason they are paying such a high rate of return is because if you invest in them you WILL NEVER SEE YOUR PRINCIPAL again. Don't do it - high yields often mean high risk. Have you driven around town lately to see what is happening to commercial real estate?
These guys are so desperate for new "investors" (i. e. "suckers") they will do anything to get your hard earned cash. The banks have already realized they are crooks - don't become the lender of last resort.
Also, please do not rush into stocks because the headlines are saying we are in for the biggest bear market rally since 1933. Stop and think about that for a moment. 1933! Where exactly were we bouncing from back then?
Please pull out your historical charts.
http://stockcharts.com/charts/historical/djia1900.html
If you are a trader, or an investment advisor with years of experience, you may be able to play this rally. If you are not, please don't buy all the bull shit you hear. These people have a vested interest in selling stocks.
I remember my days as an intern at a certain "financial planning" company. I worked as an assistant to financial planners. I decided NOT to be a financial planner because of what was going on there. (Granted, there are some very good financial planners out there, but they are not the flashy kind of guys and gals that most people gravitate toward.)
I also remember my days as an Investment Sales Representative (and later Supervisor) at your local community bank. I remember the feeling I got when I would put people in the appropriate product for their risk tolerance & time horizon. I knew I had done the right thing for the customer, but I knew I would soon be called in to my manager's office, after selling a boring CD or Annuity to an 70 year old lady. It was approximately 1997.
"Why didn't you sell them on mutual funds? You know you get a higher commission?" To which I would answer, "It didn't seem appropriate, given her risk profile." The boss would then say, but didn't you show her the CHART?" The "CHART" was a graph showing the S&P 500 and it's gains since 1955 or so. I would counter that it wasn't an accurate chart to show, because it did not accurately portray the risk associated with stock investments. It excluded the time period from 1929 to 1954. This woman was retired. She needed her last $200,000 in the world to live off of. I wasn't being a good steward if I put her in risky assets. My boss would act very irritated and make suggestions under his breath that I would be better in operations. And so it was, eventually I moved into operations, which I loved. Sales was not for me.
Now, this is not to say that if this woman would have been 30, 40, or maybe even 50 with a lot of assets, that I wouldn't have recommended mutual funds as part of her portfolio. I would have; IF her risk tolerance and time horizon were appropriate. But, you see, this wasn't very good for sales. I was too smart for sales, or to honest. I would do much better in operations. And I did.
I am currently reading a book by Aaron Clarey called, "Behind The Housing Crash". It reminds me of what I was experiencing back in the day. He was going through a very similar thing as a credit analyst not long after I was listening to my bosses tell me why mutual funds would always go up over time. Buy his book - it is worth every penny. I laughed out loud in several parts, probably because I could relate, although in a different time and place. I was worried about the dot-com bubble at the time, and how it had inflated stocks. A little while later, he was worried about the housing bubble, and he was right to be worried. Anyway, it is a great read, especially if you want to understand the nature of the housing bubble.
OK - that was a tangent. Goodnight.
Wednesday, November 26, 2008
Mumbai
Just more horrific evidence of what we are up against.
I am actually impressed with the statement from the Obama team. Surprised, but impressed. We'll see what more he has to say. I guess Biden was right, he is going to be tested. I hope it isn't as bad as I think it will be. I am sure he is starting to think a bit about how Bush felt when he was informed of the 9/11 attacks. Nothing like on the job training. It just reminds me we have to stand together as Americans to face this threat, no matter what our economic & political views.
http://www.politico.com/news/stories/1108/16020.html
I am actually impressed with the statement from the Obama team. Surprised, but impressed. We'll see what more he has to say. I guess Biden was right, he is going to be tested. I hope it isn't as bad as I think it will be. I am sure he is starting to think a bit about how Bush felt when he was informed of the 9/11 attacks. Nothing like on the job training. It just reminds me we have to stand together as Americans to face this threat, no matter what our economic & political views.
http://www.politico.com/news/stories/1108/16020.html
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
