Monday, September 20, 2010

Deflation 101

I was shopping with a friend the other day and she inadvertently gave me a little lesson in deflation I would like to share.

Deflation: A general decline in prices, often caused by a reduction in the supply of money or credit.
or: A reduction in the level of NATIONAL INCOME and output, usually accompanied by a fall in the general price level.

Now, the following tale is only about one transaction, and I am aware that deflation is defined as a general fall in prices across the entire economy, but I still feel it offers a clear illustration of what deflation looks like in everyday life.

My friend and I were at Barnes and Noble. I was looking for a copy of a Harry Potter book my daughter needed for free reading time at school. It didn't take me long to find it. It was $9.99.
I bought the book and began looking for my friend, as she was browsing in a different part of the store. She walked up to me with a "used" copy of the book she had just found on the other side of the store. It looked exactly like the new book I had just purchased. The difference: it was $3. So, being a rational human (most of the time), I immediately returned the $10 book and purchased the $3 book. I then thanked my friend for saving me $7. That, my friends, is very rapid, deflation.

It is happening all across the country. Retailers are being forced to slash prices to sell their oversupply of goods. Why? There is too much "stuff" out there, and not enough demand. Because of high household debt burdens, unemployment, and increased savings, people are much more price sensitive than they were during the boom. Consequently, retailers have to lower prices to get people to buy anything. Once people realize they have been paying way too much for things, they stop paying too much.

Have you noticed the rise of the thrift store? This is also a result of deflation.

So, perhaps we should look at who will survive. Will it be Barnes & Noble, Amazon, Borders, or Half Price Books? Due to the rise of e-books, there is probably only room for one in the space.
If you can pick the winner and short the losers, you will make a lot of money.

How about OfficeMax, Staples and Office Depot? Again, only one will survive, pick the winner and get paid.

Walgreens, CVS, Rite Aid....I could go on and on.

Circuit City lost out to Best Buy. Linen's and Things lost out to Bed Bath and Beyond.

Don't deny deflation, don't fear it. Profit from it.

Critical Week

Yes, I am still short...and right now it hurts. However, I have not changed my opinion about the stock market. As a matter of fact, I am more bearish now than ever. I am not suggesting the average investor short stocks. This is a very risky strategy. But unless you have a 20+ year time horizon, you should avoid them altogether, at least for now. After the next downturn, you will be able to buy some large blue chip dividend paying stocks VERY cheap.

I have no doubt that this rally is being driven by traders and the same very large banks that were bailed out by us, the taxpayers.

The stocks that are dragging the indexes up are trading at very high multiples. Salesforce.com (CRM) is an example. Also, look into GMCR, NFLX, PCLN, and SHLD.

The headline reason for today's rally? Home builder sentiment is better than expected. Seriously? I mean, home builders feel better about things, so that means you should by stocks. A few components driving the Dow: Home Depot (16.4 p/e), Alcoa (39.69 p/e), CAT (p/e 29.3).

Oh, and the NBER (National Bureau of Economic Research) says the Recession is over...so it must be.

This is a very important week for traders. I believe market direction will change dramatically in the next few days.

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Obvious Short*

This is what the 10-yr chart of GMCR looks like:


Now, look at the chart of the long China ETF, FXI, just prior to its demise in Nov 2007:

I didn't short China then, though I did a bit later, soon enough to take some advantage of the fall.

My point is this:

Every once in a while, there are some obvious bubble/story stocks out there that are easy shorts and GMCR is one of them.

http://money.cnn.com/2009/06/03/pf/green_mountain_coffee_stock.fortune/index.htm

There was an article in the WSJ:

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703376504575491253935081606.html

They bought another coffee company to sell off its assets and use the proceeds from those assets to pay off their own debts. Would a truly healthy company need to do such a thing? In addition, could they do it if their stock was not trading at a totally unrealistic price based on valuation?

It reminds me of the Qwest acquisition of US West at the height of the tech bubble.
The acquirer, who knows its earnings are unsustainable, has an astronomical P/E (GMCR trades at 54.8 times earnings), and has too much debt, buys a profitable, boring, low P/E company and saddles it with debt only to sell its assets to service that debt at a later date. This is parasitic behavior, and perhaps it is the only way GMCR will survive.


Now, I am not saying they sell a bad product. On the contrary. I am just saying their stock and, hence their company is extremely overvalued. I also see their product being a victim of the deflationary recession we are in. I mean, who is going to buy these overpriced machines that only make one cup of coffee at a time? From what I can tell they retail from between $100 and $200. I can get a pretty good coffee maker that makes 12 cups at Target for $36. Oh, I know, they are stylish. They look cool and expensive, like something you don't really need, but want. Not a good place to be as the consumer pulls back.

In my humble opinion, if sales don't fall at GMCR due to the recession, it should be trading at about $9 a share. I am looking to buy put options today.

When the market corrects, it will.

*As always, trade at your own risk. Shorting stocks can result in large losses if you don't know what you are doing, and sometimes does even if you do.

Jobs Data

Tomorrow's jobs data is crucial for the markets in the short term. We are also approaching options expiration (Friday). Should be interesting.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Rally on Election Hopes?

This rally is unsustainable. The market may not be rational, but it eventually self corrects.

I know we hope that a change in government will fix things, but it won't. This Depression is A-political.

This is just a technical bounce. If you are a trader you already missed the move, don't chase it.

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Steve Keen

Thanks to an old friend from high school (thanks John!), I have found another source of great economic information. This is not easy, as much that is out there is very "surface" and many economists that are in the employ of large financial institutions or the government have a vested interest in not digging deeper, especially if the truth that lies underneath the headlines is hard to stomach.

Mr. Keen seems an exception to this. He has done rigorous analysis on the very questions I have been pondering, such as how GDP has been debt driven for the past decade or so, and what the effects of that on future growth (or contraction in this case) will be.

One of the things I do on this blog is try to make economics understandable to the regular person out there, so I tend to use simpler language and not too much empirical data.

However, if you want the data to back up what I have been saying...you can get it on Keen's site.

http://www.debtdeflation.com/blogs


Happy reading!

Tuesday, September 7, 2010

I Love Art Cashin

Not LOVE, love, like I love my husband, I mean I love watching him on CNBC.

He is so classy, but doesn't act arrogant like so many of the younger, "slick" traders who haven't been through near what he has.

Also, he is right often, and this clip is no exception. (although I would say 10-15 years, not 7) He is able to see the big picture, and is refreshingly honest.