Robert Khuzami, Director of the Division of Enforcement at the SEC sums up the case against Goldman best, since he is the one bringing the charges*:
"The product was new and complex but the deception and conflicts are old and simple," said Robert Khuzami, Director of the Division of Enforcement. "Goldman wrongly permitted a client that was betting against the mortgage market to heavily influence which mortgage securities to include in an investment portfolio, while telling other investors that the securities were selected by an independent, objective third party."
What pops out at me is "..wrongly permitted a client that was betting against the mortgage market to heavily influence which mortgage securities to include in an investment portfolio, while telling other investors that the securities were selected by an independent third party."
PROBLEM: THE THIRD PARTY WAS NOT INDEPENDENT. THEREFORE, GOLDMAN WAS LYING (what prosecutors call fraud) TO THE BUYER OF THE CDO's THEY WERE SELLING!
In addition:
According to the SEC's complaint, filed in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, the marketing materials for the CDO known as ABACUS 2007-AC1 (ABACUS) all represented that the RMBS portfolio underlying the CDO was selected by ACA Management LLC (ACA), a third party with expertise in analyzing credit risk in RMBS. The SEC alleges that undisclosed in the marketing materials and unbeknownst to investors, the Paulson & Co. hedge fund, which was poised to benefit if the RMBS defaulted, played a significant role in selecting which RMBS should make up the portfolio.
I understand that Goldman is a "market maker" and that they were not acting as an "investment advisor" on this deal. Market makers are not obligated to disclose to buyers or sellers who is on the other side of a trade. A market, by definition requires a buyer and seller, each of whom have different perspectives, preferences and perhaps even different information. Goldman's clients understand this too. The PROBLEM is that Goldman LIED about the fact that the firm which selected the securities in the CDO was not only NOT independent; but short. According to the SEC, Goldman, in its own prospectus on the CDO it was selling, guaranteed that the party selecting the components of the CDO was INDEPENDENT. This was not true. It was the same party that was on the other side of the trade.
So, let's try to come up with a good analogy, because most of them out there are insufficient to explain the SEC's case.
My God...I can't come up with one. I love analogies, but I don't think there is one in this case. I bet if I read:
Section 17(a) of the Securities Act of 1933, Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, and Exchange Act Rule 10b-5
I would be able to come up with one. I will read it and get back to you on that. Did you see the date of the Act? 1933! I am sure it was written in reponse to activities later blamed for causing the crash of 1929 and the Great Depression.
I am sure the SEC code is probably as arcane and complex as...well...umm...perhaps a CDO! But I will still read that section.
My point is this: Goldman has been doing deals like this for years. Does this make them bad people? NO. Should they be demonized? Perhaps not. They, like all people who make mistakes, probably thought they were doing what was right. However, they probably do violate SEC rules...often. This time they got caught. This time they got caught breaking the rules of the game.
Are the rules of the game fair and just? I have no idea. Probably not. Is the entire financial system based on an incentive problems? Yes. To name a few: FDIC, too big to fail, and commercial banks being allowed to participate in proprietary trading.
Their are "bad guys" everywhere. The government, the over leveraged public, overleveraged firms, the big banks, the Wall Street firms, the relators, the ratings agencies...and more.
Some facts remain:
Goldman, and the other investment banks will never be the same. Financial reform is coming, like it or not. Goldman will probably settle. (I doubt this will go to trial.) But their stock is overvalued...along with most of the financials.
And if Lloyd Blankfein does not stop talking so much, public sentiment is going to turn even more harshly against Goldman. The average American is hurting. Nothing ticks them off more than hearing a guy who needed their tax dollars to save his firm talk about how Goldman is so successful because it pays its brilliant employees so well. If they are all so brilliant, why did they need the Government to save their asses? He is just WAY out of touch with the average person out there. People really do not want to hear him on Charlie Rose whining about how he didn't want to be a leader during this crisis because it was hard. Or how his poor people have been working 19 hour days. I mean...my God...who the hell cares? Did it reduce their effective hourly wage, say, from $2000 an hour, to $1000 an hour? I don't blanking care Blankenfein! Their are regular people all over the country who work at least that hard. All I know is Wall Street, and hence their livelihood, wouldn't exist without the average American Taxpayer. The free market would have destroyed their risk laden business model. And our stupid government should have let it.
When you need the government to bail you out, you follow their rules. Is this right, or just? Perhaps not. But it is a reality our financial institutions must face because of their greed and ignorance. It is what it is.
*The info and quotes I am using here come directly from the SEC itself.
http://www.sec.gov/news/press/2010/2010-59.htm
Monday, May 3, 2010
Sunday, May 2, 2010
Mulling "The Big Short"
"The Big Short" by Michael Lewis is great. Buy it. Read it.
Betweeen reading that book and the interview(s) I saw with Lloyd Blankfein this weekend, my brain is rebooting. Processing it all...and trying to decide what to do with it.
When that happens, I promise a fabulous post.
Betweeen reading that book and the interview(s) I saw with Lloyd Blankfein this weekend, my brain is rebooting. Processing it all...and trying to decide what to do with it.
When that happens, I promise a fabulous post.
Friday, April 30, 2010
The Daily Show & Fab Tourre
Hilarious:
| The Daily Show With Jon Stewart | Mon - Thurs 11p / 10c | |||
| Who Wants to Beat a Millionaire | ||||
| www.thedailyshow.com | ||||
| ||||
Goldman Puts
Wow, it has been very satisfying to own GS puts this week. Only wish it was big time... but still fun, and satisfying.
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/downgrades-add-to-goldmans-woes-2010-04-30
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/downgrades-add-to-goldmans-woes-2010-04-30
Tuesday, April 27, 2010
Parenting & Inner Peace?
Perhaps I should change my tag to: "economics and politics", or... "distracted, anxiety ridden mother, who is more interested in the case against Goldman Sachs than anything else". Lately, it seems that would be more honest.
I am having a real hard time focusing on parenting lately. Inner peace? Well, it is just not fair:
to glimpse it an have it turn out to be fleeting and ultimately unsustainable unless I give up every worldly endeavor I have.
It sometimes all seems like too much.
I made a killing in the trading arena today. I hate being right sometimes, just as much as I love it.
I am going to go give my wonderful kids a kiss and call it a day.
GS analysis will follow tomorrow, I hope.
I am having a real hard time focusing on parenting lately. Inner peace? Well, it is just not fair:
to glimpse it an have it turn out to be fleeting and ultimately unsustainable unless I give up every worldly endeavor I have.
It sometimes all seems like too much.
I made a killing in the trading arena today. I hate being right sometimes, just as much as I love it.
I am going to go give my wonderful kids a kiss and call it a day.
GS analysis will follow tomorrow, I hope.
Monday, April 26, 2010
Whitney Right Again
Love her - She has guts,integrity, class, wit, and intelligence. She also happens to be right!
Sunday, April 25, 2010
Why I Own SHLD Put Options*
*And will be buying as many as I can this week:
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/sears-starts-to-look-like-a-retailer-again-2010-04-23?dist=WSJfeed&siteid=WSJ
"Many of Lambert's moves in rebuilding the company were counter intuitive, to say the least."
Jim Cramer likes Mike Lambert.
http://seekingalpha.com/article/197891-cramer-s-lightning-round-all-alone-with-eddie-lampert-4-8-10
Wow, they have lost market share! But they are increasing sales none the less! Wow! Amaaaazing! Or accounting crap orchestrated by the Gomez-Lambert team. Give me a break.
Which is more likely, a former hedge fund manager is making huge profits based on accounting irregularity's and government stimulus funds, or people are going to start flocking to Sears and K-Mart in droves because they like Selena Gomez?
So Jim Cramer loves this guy...and I don't. Nothing personal, just you see, you have a former hedge fund guy trying to turn around a failing retailer in the midst of the next Great Recession and you know what? He is not really trying to turn it around.
From WSJ article above: "It is too early to tell if Sears' sales uptick is just a freak occurrence, or if the company has made some changes that will stick." (Hint: It's a freak occurence!)
Lampert knows Sears is going down and his old hedge fund buddies are supporting him even though they know it too. Hence, a P/E of 59.8 in an industry that is trading at 23.8 times earnings when it should be trading at 13 times earnings. Perhaps 7.
Short, Short, Short!*
*Trade at you own risk. I smell a great big blanking RAT!
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/sears-starts-to-look-like-a-retailer-again-2010-04-23?dist=WSJfeed&siteid=WSJ
"Many of Lambert's moves in rebuilding the company were counter intuitive, to say the least."
Jim Cramer likes Mike Lambert.
http://seekingalpha.com/article/197891-cramer-s-lightning-round-all-alone-with-eddie-lampert-4-8-10
Wow, they have lost market share! But they are increasing sales none the less! Wow! Amaaaazing! Or accounting crap orchestrated by the Gomez-Lambert team. Give me a break.
Which is more likely, a former hedge fund manager is making huge profits based on accounting irregularity's and government stimulus funds, or people are going to start flocking to Sears and K-Mart in droves because they like Selena Gomez?
So Jim Cramer loves this guy...and I don't. Nothing personal, just you see, you have a former hedge fund guy trying to turn around a failing retailer in the midst of the next Great Recession and you know what? He is not really trying to turn it around.
From WSJ article above: "It is too early to tell if Sears' sales uptick is just a freak occurrence, or if the company has made some changes that will stick." (Hint: It's a freak occurence!)
Lampert knows Sears is going down and his old hedge fund buddies are supporting him even though they know it too. Hence, a P/E of 59.8 in an industry that is trading at 23.8 times earnings when it should be trading at 13 times earnings. Perhaps 7.
Short, Short, Short!*
*Trade at you own risk. I smell a great big blanking RAT!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
